WiiNintendo

IGN - 80/100
A great first step on Wii, as it uses more than 25 gestures, IR aiming, and has a ton of features above the original game in the form of new items, missions, gameplay modes (favors and blackmailing specifically), and RPG elements. More important than any list of numbers and features though, is the fact that The Godfather is just fun to play.
Read Full Review

Official Nintendo Magazine UK - 80/100
The Godfather is the perfect example of how Wii controls can make an average game better. It’s a shame it doesn’t look better, but this is still highly recommended for action fans. [Apr 2007, p.89]

Yahoo! Games - 80/100
We haven’t been bowled over by most of the Wii-makes hitting shelves so far, but The Godfather is a definite exception. The controls and extra content more than make up for the fact that the game already looks visually dated.
Read Full Review

More should be pouring in at Metacritic